Mon thru Thurs,
6am to 7pm
Fri thru Sat,
6am to 8pm
Closed Sunday
14743 North State Street
Middlefield OH 44062

440.632.1939

GIFT CARD SPECIAL!
Starting November 1 through November 30, 2024, for every $50.00 you spend on a gift card, you will receive a $10.00 gift voucher! Visit our Gift Shop or purchase your gift cards online!

OUR MENUS: Good, Old-Fashioned Amish Cooking

Breakfast

Lunch & Dinner

For the Kids

Online Ordering for Carryout

Today's Specials at Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen

Today's Specials

Chipotle Bowl

choose pork or chicken

Tomato Basil Soup with Grilled Cheese

Soup of the Day

Cream of Potato Soup

Coffee of the Day

Double Dutch Chocolate

ONLINE STORE

Baked goods, gifts and more!

Welcome to the ON-LINE STORE at Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen, where you can enjoy the best in Amish baked goods, hand-made gifts, gift cards, and more!

Our Amish bakers offer a huge selection of pies, cookies, and breads made from recipes handed down through the generations... delicious treats that can be delivered to your home!

Plus, don't miss our selection of other delicious items, including jams & jellies, peanut butter spread, homemade noodles, popcorn, coffee, candy, and more.

Our selection of handcrafted toys, including magnetic train cards, authentic metal horse & buggy set and wooden backhoe are here for all your shopping needs.

Come on in and take a look around!

TAKE THEIR WORD!

What our customers are saying

Your bakery and food service is the best Thank you Mary Yoder's is always a great reason for a road trip

—Gianna

I would patronize this establishment 7 days a week if that were feasible! Unfortunately I live about 40 miles away, but anytime I'm even near the area I make it a point to stop in for a meal. The food is beyond outstanding in quality, price and value, and the staff is exceptionally diligent and friendly. If you haven't been there, you're missing out!

—Jon

I ordered 3 elderberry pies and thought I would send an email thanking you. First, the extraordinary care and layers of packaging really impressed me. The pies were in perfect condition on arrival. Not a crumb out of place. I put two pies in the freezer and we are currently enjoying the sugar free pie. It is probably one of the best pies i have ever eaten. I was a little leary of ordering a fragile pie to be mailed, but those concerns were unnecessary. And, best of all, the pie is wonderful. I will definitely order again in the future.

—Mary

Join the conversation!

More from Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen

amish recipes from mary yoders amish kitchen

Delicious Amish Recipes

Monthly Local Events

join mary yoders amish kitchen birthday club

Join our Birthday Club